What I’ve Been Listening To: America/ History: America’s Greatest Hits (Re-Post)

America’s vocal harmonies and smooth folk rock sound make for one of the best ’70s greatest hits compilations

On Monday, I found myself listening to America. I realize the trio has been dismissed by some critics as a Crosby, Stills & Nash knockoff. If anything, frankly, I would consider sounding like one of the best harmony-singing bands of all time as a compliment. But that may just be me. In any case, I’ve loved America’s music for many years and always enjoy revisiting it.

My listening experience made me want to post about the album that started my America journey as a nine- or 10-year-old back in Germany: History: America’s Greatest Hits. Then, I nebulously recalled a previous musing about their first compilation from November 1975. Checking my blog revealed a post from September 2018. Yes, I sometimes have to search my own stuff to remember what I previously wrote! 🙂

When it comes to old posts, sometimes, I wish I had written them differently. My views may have evolved. I also guess there’s a certain learning curve here. In this case, I was happy to see that I continue to fully stand behind each word I wrote almost three years ago. Therefore, I decided to do something I rarely do: Re-publish a previous post.

– Re-Post –

I was nine or 10 years old when I listened to History: America’s Greatest Hits for the first time. The album grabbed me right from the beginning. It was one of the vinyl records my older sister had, which among others also included Carole King’s TapestryCrosby, Stills, Nash & Young’s Déjà Vu; and Simon & Garfunkel’s Greatest Hits – all albums I dig to this day.

Recently, I rediscovered History. To me, it’s one of the best greatest hits compilations I know, which were released in the ’70s. Others that come to my mind are Neil Young’s DecadeEagles’ Their Greatest Hits (1971-1975), Santana’s Greatest HitsSteely Dan’s Greatest Hits and the aforementioned Simon & Garfunkel album. There are probably some others I’m forgetting – in any case, it’s not meant to be a complete list.

I recall reading somewhere that America were dismissed by some as a Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young knock-off. While I generally don’t think highly of music critics in the first place, I feel this notion is silly. Yes, America’s three-part harmony vocals are reminiscent of CSN/CSNY, but this doesn’t make them a copycat or somehow bad artists! On the contrary, if anything, the vocal similarity to CSN/CSNY is a huge accomplishment – after all, there aren’t many bands that can harmonize like CSN/CSNY did! On to History.

America (from left): Gerry Beckley, Dan Peek & Dewey Bunnell

Released in November 1975, History encompasses America’s 11 most successful singles at the time, plus an edited take of Sandman from their December 1971 eponymous debut. In addition to that album, History includes material from four additional studio records: Homecoming (November 1972), Hat Trick (October 1973), Holiday (June 1974) and Hearts (March 1975).

History opens with one of my favorite America tunes: A Horse With No Name from their debut album. It was written by Dewey Bunnell, who formed America with Dan Peek and Gerry Beckley in London in 1970. The three had met there in the mid-’60s as high school students whose fathers were stationed on a nearby U.S. Air Force base.

A Horse With No Name became America’s most successful single topping the Billboard Hot 100. It also stirred some controversy due to the similarity of Bunnell’s voice to Neil Young, and what some viewed as mediocre lyrics. Coincidentally, the song knocked Young’s Heart Of Gold off the Billboard Hot 100 top spot. I really don’t care whether it sounds like Young, who by the way is one of my favorite artists. With its two chords and killer harmony vocals, this tune simply gives me goosebumps each time I hear it.

Ventura Highway, another Bunnell composition, is from the Homecoming album. When I listen to this song and close my eyes, I can literally picture myself in an open convertible driving on the Pacific Coast Highway 1 from L.A. up north to San Francisco. I actually did that trip in 1980 as a 14-year-old, together with my parents. Even though we had a lame station wagon as a rental, not some hot convertible, it was an unforgettable experience! Ventura Highway became a top 10 Billboard single for America, reaching no. 8 and no. 3 on the Hot 100 and Easy Listening charts, respectively.

Another beautiful tune is Lonely People, which was credited to Dan Peek and his wife Catherine Peek. The song was written a few weeks after their marriage. An obituary in TMR that appeared in the wake of Peek’s death in July 2011 at the age of 60 quotes him: “I wrote it probably within a month of getting married to my long-lost love Catherine…I always felt like a melancholy, lonely person. And now I felt like I’d won.” America  initially recorded Lonely People for their fourth studio album Holiday. It topped the Billboard Easy Listening chart and peaked at no. 5 on the Hot 100.

One of my favorite songs on History written by Gerry Beckley is Sister Golden Hair. Recorded for America’s fifth studio album Hearts, the tune also became the band’s second no. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100. The lyrics were inspired by Jackson Browne. In this context, John Corbett’s America Revisited quotes Beckley: “Jackson Browne has a knack, an ability to put words to music, that is much more like the L.A. approach to just genuine observation as opposed to simplifying it down to its bare essentials… and it was that style of his which led to a song of mine, “Sister Golden Hair,” which is probably the more L.A. of my lyrics.” I guess this means in addition to CSN/CSNY, America also stole from Browne – unbelievable!

The last song I’d like to call out is the final track on the History compilation:  Woman Tonight. It’s another tune from the Hearts album and was written by Peek. Released as the third single, it charted within the top 50 in the U.S.

History was produced by none other than George Martin, who had started working with America on their fourth studio album Holiday. Martin also remixed the first seven tracks on History, which he had not produced originally. The compilation became a huge success in the U.S., giving America a no. 3 on the Billboard 200. In October 1986, the Recording Industry Association of America certified the album 4X Multi-Platinum.

Since History, America have released 12 additional studio albums, 10 live records and numerous other compilations. Now in their 51st year [updated from original post – CMM], America continue to perform, featuring co-founders Beckley and Bunnell. Peek left the band in May 1977, long before his death, after he had renewed his Christian faith.

– End of Re-Post –

Apparently, America will be touring the U.S. starting in late summer. According to their current schedule listed on their website, things are set to kick off in North Bethesda, Md. on August 13. Some of the other gigs include Hyannis, Mass. (Aug 27); Mulvane, Kan. (Sep 11); Lawrence, Kan. (Sep 25); Reno, Nev. (Oct 2), Mankato, Minn (Oct 22); and San Antonio (Nov 14). The last currently listed show is Sarasota, Fla. (Nov 21). I saw America once in the late ’90s on Long Island, N.Y., and they sounded fantastic.

Sources: Wikipedia; TMR; John Corbett: “America Revisited”, AccessBackstage.com, May 29, 2004; RIAA Gold & Platinum certifications; America website; YouTube

18 thoughts on “What I’ve Been Listening To: America/ History: America’s Greatest Hits (Re-Post)”

  1. I also think History is a pretty good compilation. I always tried to keep a copy of it. I don’t think there was quite enough good hits to fill it up completely, but almost. But I got to admit I like Captain and Tennille’s version of Muskrat Love better than America’s. Ha ha.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. How did I miss this Christian? Well I know… I’ve been working a lot…but I agree…I don’t see them as a copy or knockoff.
    My favorite is Lonely People but I think their masterpiece was Sister Golden Hair…I just happen to like the other more.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. No worries, Max! I pretty much dig the entire album. I really like America’s harmony singing and their laid back sound.

      When I listen to “Ventura Highway”, I can literally picture myself driving on some convertible on coastal highway no. 1 from LA to San Francisco.

      In fact, when I came to the States for the first time as a 14-year-old on a summer vacation with my parents, that’s exactly what we did. Except we did that drive some lame rental station wagon! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes it’s hard to be cool in a station wagon!!!
        I like them also…and when I listen to Horse with No Name…I’m in a desert. It’s not like America didn’t mix it up…from Neil Youngish A Horse With No Name to a George Harrsion like Sister Golden Hair…they evolved and were their own band.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. It literally was a station wagon very similar to the one in National Lampoon’s Vacation. 🙂

        That being said, back then, I didn’t care that much about it. It was a five-week vacation and definitely one of the most memorable I’ve ever had.

        Coming from a relatively small country like Germany to the vast U.S. for the first time, especially out west, was a mind-boggling experience. The seemingly endless dimensions and traveling on highways that run like straight lines from where you are up to the horizon were breath-taking

        We visited various national parks like Yosemite, Bryce Canyon, Grand Canyon, Mesa Verde, Monument Valley. The landscapes out west are just unbelievable.

        Last but but not least, seeing New York City’s skyscrapers for the first time was quite impressive as well. Visiting D.C. was great as well. We did so many things during that one vacation.

        Liked by 1 person

      3. Five-week vacation yea…that had to be a lot of fun.
        I can’t imagine how you felt. When Bailey talks to Maria in Germany she talks about how her dad and mom ride their bicycles to work everyday…because they are so close to everything. She asked Bailey about how I got to work…she cannot believe how far I travel…36 miles one way. We live in the country…America is so spread out.

        Man that must have been such a feeling Christian to see all of that….and New York on top of all of that.

        Liked by 1 person

      4. It did leave a lasting impression, Max, that’s for sure. I still remember certain moments of that trip like looking down into the Grand Canyon for seeing Las Vegas at night for the first time, even though all of this happened nearly 41 years ago!

        I guess it’s not a coincidence I wanted to come back to America as to study. Though I had not planned to stay! 🙂


  3. I like America, never really saw them as derivative of anybody. But for me they’re pretty much just a band I listen to and/or sing along with if they come on the radio, nothing more.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I can’t deny there’s a certain degree of sentimentalism at play here when it comes to that album.

      I saw America once and did enjoy them. But instead of catching another show, I would rather invest the money in a ticket to see somebody else.

      Or use the money toward a ticket to see McCartney one more time as soon as possible. I’m afraid there are very few opportunities left, if any!


      1. If America came to our favorite outdoor venue up in Lowell and it was going to be a nice summer night, I’d think about it. Yes, I’d see McCartney again at any price and bring Sonny Boy. He got a chill seeing the Stones so he’d probably faint seeing a Beatle. BTW, have you reviewed McCartney III? I can’t recall. I listened to it and it’s not bad in a homemade sort of way.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Dare I say it, for McCartney, I would come to Boston, if he wouldn’t play any place closer.

        Yep, I reviewed McCartney III and also think it’s not bad overall. McCartney II, on the other hand, never spoke to me.


      3. I liked “Coming Up,” the rest of it I don’t know. It’s interesting that pretty much everybody hated it initially but if you read Wikipedia, critical assessments have improved over the years.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: