If I Could Only Take One

My desert island tune by James Gang

Another Wednesday is upon us, which means time to pick another tune to take to that imaginary desert island. I’m up to the letter “J”, and taking a look at my music library reveals artists and bands like Joe Jackson, The Jackson 5, The Jayhawks, Jean-Michel Jarre, Nora Jones and Janis Joplin. Each would be a good choice, except I’ve covered them more often than my pick James Gang.

I only know a handful of James Gang tunes, which made my selection pretty easy: Funk #49. Co-written by band members Joe Walsh (vocals, guitars, percussion, piano, keyboards), Jim Fox (drums, percussion, organ, piano, keyboards) and Dale Peters (bass guitar, percussion, vocals), the song is from the group’s sophomore album James Gang Rides Again, released in July 1970. It also appeared separately as a single that same year.

Like James Gang’s other charting songs, Funk #49 was moderately successful in the U.S., reaching no. 59 on the Billboard Hot 100. It did better in Canada where it climbed to no. 26, marking their highest-charting single there. This doesn’t change the fact that I love this tune!

Following are some additional insights from Songfacts:

The James Gang is best known for their guitarist, Joe Walsh, whose playing on this track helped establish him as a superstar axeman. Walsh joined the Cleveland-based group in 1969 after making a name for himself as one of the top guitar men in Ohio. He replaced Glenn Schwartz in the band, who Walsh considers a mentor. They were a 5-piece when Walsh joined, but were down to three (like popular acts Cream and The Jimi Hendrix Experience) when they released their second album James Gang Rides Again.

With just three members, it meant Walsh had to play both rhythm and lead guitar parts, and also sing (he got a lot more help when he joined the Eagles in 1975). It was quite a learning experience for Walsh, who left the James Gang in 1971 after recording three studio albums with the group.

The song is about a girlfriend whose wild ways the singer just can’t tame…There isn’t much in the way of lyrics, as the song is mostly a showcase for Walsh’s guitar work. He explained in the book The Guitar Greats, “I came up with the basic guitar lick, and the words never really impressed me intellectually, but they seemed to fit somehow. It was a real good example of how we put things together, bearing in mind that it was a three piece group, and I don’t think that there was any overdubbing. The only thing we really added was the percussion middle part, which the three of us actually played, putting some parts on top of the drums, but that’s the three piece James Gang, and that’s the energy and kind of the symmetry we were all about.”

“Funk #49” became a staple of Album Oriented Rock and Classic Rock radio, but it wasn’t the biggest chart hit for the James Gang – that would be “Walk Away,” which made #51 in 1971 and was later reworked for Walsh’s 1976 solo album You Can’t Argue with a Sick Mind. “Funk #49” is one of Joe Walsh’s most popular songs, and by the mid-’70s he admitted that he couldn’t stand playing it any more, but did so because fans loved it.

Sources: Wikipedia; YouTube


9 thoughts on “If I Could Only Take One”

  1. Their music is so much fun. My favorite is Midnight Man but I like a lot of their songs and a few album cuts. This one and Walk Away.
    I love what the drummers do in the middle part of this before Joe’s solo.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. they were a pretty decent band to be sure. Growing up in Canada, I didn’t hear them much , since at the time I was a top 30, AM listener, but I think they were big on FM . Seems like my older brother liked them back in that age.
    If I had to take just one album from the J’s…tough call. I’d opt for a greatest hits of either Billy Joel or Joe Jackson (or reluctantly go for ‘an Innocent Man’ or ‘Night and Day’ respectively if some foul overlord didn’t allow compilations!)

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I have the ‘Rides Again’ album on vinyl from WAY back. I was a big Joe Walsh fan (‘Barnstorm’ still ranks one of my favourite albums) and bought James Gang on the back of that. I was / am also an Eagles fan, but I’ve never really married the two together … I though Joe was better as his own man. But hey – what do I know? 😉 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  4. A great tune for sure. At the time this was on the radio, none of us thought of or even cared about whether it was or was not a single. This was just right in the sweet spot of all the bluesy guitar-oriented stuff that was out then. Perfect fore downing a cold one, lighting up a J, and playing air guitar. Cut to years later and now I play this thing on guitar all the time for fun (literally just the other day). I never bothered to learn the whole song but I can pretty much play up through those killer descending licks. Walsh is another guy whose guitar playing I like but I wouldn’t give you much for his singing. But what a great addition to the Eagles. And he gets to hang out with Ringo!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yep. Unfortunately, Joe isn’t part of the current All-Starr Band line-up, which includes Steve Lukather, Colin Hay, Warren Ham, Gregg Bissonette, Hamish Stuart and Edgar Winter. I just saw a few weeks ago, they announced a second leg of 2022 tour dates for Sep and Oct. Knock on wood I get to see these guys in June during the first leg, which are all rescheduled dates.


    1. Elton John’s “Yellow Brick Road” would be an excellent choice. I guess my favorite tune by John would be “Rocket Man.”

      The twist about my picks is they need to be artists I’ve only rarely covered or not covered at all. I suppose it’s a pretty arbitrary way to write about such artists. 🙂

      Without these self-imposed restrictions my picks would be very different. Perhaps when I’m done with 24 picks, I’ll do a playlist of my 24 desert island tunes I would choose without limitations.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: