I make no bones about it – my decision to get a ticket for Neil Young & Crazy Horse a few months ago was driven by my emotions for an artist I’ve loved for 40-plus years; and the thought this may be my second and final chance to see him after a great 2018 solo gig in Boston. The fact this would be a first with Neil’s long-time backing band Crazy Horse was icing on the cake. Showtime finally came on Wednesday (May 15), at Forest Hills Stadium in Queens, a venue with a storied past, where the likes of The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, The Who, Bob Dylan and Jimi Hendrix performed. And what a rock fest it was, despite dicey weather!
As I usually do leading up to a gig, I checked recent setlists of the Love Earth Tour on Setlist.fm and live footage on YouTube. The sets looked very promising, pointing to many classics I could expect to hear. YouTube footage was more of a mixed bag, especially when it came to Young’s vocals, so I decided to adjust my expectations. Fortunately, Young’s voice turned out to be much better than I had anticipated. Even the weather gods largely cooperated. It was raining while entering the venue and waiting for the show and, as such, my waterproof rain poncho came in handy, but the precipitation largely stopped by the time Neil Young & Crazy Horse hit the stage.
A few words about Crazy Horse before getting to some music. While Young’s longtime on-and-off backing band since 1969 were a secondary consideration when purchasing my ticket, like many other fans, I had assumed Nils Lofgren would be part of the Love Earth Tour, along with bassist Billy Talbot and drummer Ralph Molina. But only two-thirds of that line-up were there, with Micah Nelson filling in for Lofgren as the second guitarist. To say it right away, Micah, a son of Willie Nelson, did a great job!
Based on commentary I saw on the Internet, I wasn’t the only fan who when they purchased their ticket didn’t realize Lofgren would still be on the road with Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band. Not even AI could have fixed the challenge of being in two places at the same time! Obviously, Lofgren’s schedule was known to the Love Earth organizers when tickets for the tour went on sale, yet I don’t recall seeing any mention of it. I think it would have been better to be transparent about Lofgren’s absence.
The Love Earth stage setup featured cool oversized props of guitar amps and road cases, which an article in Young’s online paper NYA Times Contrarian notes were “immortalized” in the 1979 documentary Rust Never Sleeps. Molina’s drum kit was on a riser placed between the giant amp props. A large black banner featuring a white running horse served as the stage backsplash. A minor wrinkle: No jumbotrons, which made it impossible to see the artists up-close for folks in the back, including this blogger.
Mirroring past Neil Young & Crazy Horse concerts, the set included a mix of electric full-band songs, which hugged a portion featuring Young solo on acoustic guitar and harmonica. Most of the music drew from ’70s and late ’60s albums, such as Everybody Knows This is Nowhere (1969), Zuma (1975) and Rust Never Sleeps (1979). Ragged Glory (1990) was also prominently represented. Additionally, there was music from Young solo albums, including Harvest (1972), Tonight’s the Night (1975) and Comes a Time (1978). The biggest surprise to me was Heart of Gold. While that’s Young’s biggest hit, I recall reading previous commentary from him that he wouldn’t perform that song.
Let’s take a look at some clips. Conditions for filming weren’t ideal, and the sound was better than what I captured. But I still hope the footage will give you an idea of the concert. After the epic opener Cortez the Killer unleashed the Horse, it was time for Cinnamon Girl. The classic track is from Young’s second studio album Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere and his first with Crazy Hose, released in May 1969.
One of my all-time favorite Neil Young songs is Powderfinger. It first appeared on the Rust Never Sleeps album with Crazy Horse, which came out in June 1997. That album was mostly recorded live with overdubs added in the studio.
Then it was time for Young’s solo acoustic set. Here’s the first song, Comes a Time, the title track off his October 1978 solo album.
One of two tour debuts was Sugar Mountain, another song by Young I’ve always loved. He composed it on his 19th birthday. The first known recording, from December 1965, is included on Young’s 2009 compilation The Archives Vol. 1 1963–1972. The song’s first released version is a live recording, which became the B-side to his 1969 single The Loner. Last but not least, the first album version was included on the excellent October 1977 compilation Decade.
Of course, I couldn’t skip the set’s closer Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black). This epic song first appeared on the aforementioned Rust Never Sleeps album.
Last but not least, here’s the first encore: Like a Hurricane, off American Stars ‘n Bars, another album Young made with Crazy Horse, released in May 1977. It was a perfect end to a great show. Perhaps the only song that could have trumped it would have been Rockin’ In the Free World, which they played as one of two encores Tuesday night at the same venue.
Here’s the setlist from Wednesday night. Based on Setlist.fm, most of it has remained constant, but Neil has made frequent tweaks, so in case you are going to catch him at an upcoming date, you likely won’t exactly get what you see below.
Setlist
• Cortez the Killer
• Cinnamon Girl
• Fuckin’ Up
• Down by the River
• Scattered (Let’s Think About Livin’)
• Roll Another Number (For the Road)
• Don’t Cry No Tears
• Mansion on the Hill (tour debut)
• Danger Bird
• Powderfinger
• Love and Only Love
• Comes a Time (Young solo acoustic)
• Heart of Gold (Young solo acoustic)
• Human Highway (Young solo acoustic)
• I Am a Child (Buffalo Springfield cover) (Young solo acoustic)
• Sugar Mountain (Young solo acoustic; tour debut)
• Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)
Encore
• Like a Hurricane
• Roll Another Number (For the Road) (Reprise)
If you dig Neil Young and want in it appears there may still be some tickets available. I imagine a good deal are for resale, so not sure about prices at this time. Neil and the Horse continue their ride this evening in Mansfield, Mass, followed by Bridgeport, Conn., tomorrow (May 18); Toronto, Ontario (May 20); Clarkston, Mich. (May 22); Chicago, Ill. (May 23); and Austin, Texas (May 27). The full schedule is here.
Last but not least, now that Neil has returned to Spotify, I’m leaving you with a Spotify playlist that mirrors the above setlist.
Sources: Wikipedia; NeilYoungArchives.com; Setlist.fm; YouTube; Spotify